Showing posts with label Monsoon forecast; IMD; Mission; statistical; dynamic; models; El Nino; IOD; normal; D S Pai; below average; Rathore; agriculture; food prices; SOI; POAMA; M Rajeevan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Monsoon forecast; IMD; Mission; statistical; dynamic; models; El Nino; IOD; normal; D S Pai; below average; Rathore; agriculture; food prices; SOI; POAMA; M Rajeevan. Show all posts

Monday, June 25, 2012

Will the IMD monsoon forecast pip global models in hitting the bulls’ eye? Probably yes!


The IMD is reduced to a butt of jokes. Two years in a row, they failed to predict the monsoon.  During 2010-2011 monsoon season, they got the forecast wrong, failing to anticipate a looming La Nina. The next year, again they missed factoring in the re-emergence of a second year La Nina and ended up with mud on their faces.

Last week the IMD revised their May forecast last week.  While their forecast of a “normal” monsoon [(viz. 96-104% of Long Period Average (LPA)] remains unchanged, rainfall shortfall is now forecasted at 4% of Long Period Average (LPA), instead of an estimated 1% earlier in May. This makes their latest forecast a downgrade of their first in May this year.

The probability for a below average monsoon [viz 90-96% of LPA] increases by a whopping 9% while those of a normal monsoon decreased 5% from their May forecast.  Since the IMD model possesses a statistical model error rate of + 5%, there is now theoretically, almost an equal probability for a below-average and a normal monsoon occurring this year. 

Can they put their infamous past behind and hit a bulls-eye this year? Most probably yes!

Sunday, April 29, 2012

Official Monsoon forecast disappoints: The IMD plays safe, hedges its bet!


The long waited official forecast of the Indian Meteorological Department (IMD) was finally announced last Thursday evening. The country is set to receive normal South West Monsoon rains in 2012, for a third year in a row. “It is a normal forecast,” said Mr Vilasrao Deshmukh, Union Minister for Science and Technology.

A forecast of normal rainfall at 99% of LPA should be reassuring news for India where the monsoon is the lifeline of a farm-dependent economy. But as they say “The devil is in the details”. So what’s the fine print? These read as follows:

(a)  Southwest monsoon seasonal rainfall for the country as a whole is most likely to be Normal (96-104%) of Long Period Average (LPA)) with the probability of 47%. Quantitatively, monsoon season rainfall is likely to be 99% of the LPA with a model error of ± 5%. The LPA of the season rainfall over the country as a whole for the period 1951-2000 is 89 cm.

(b)  The probability (24%) of season rainfall to be below normal (90-96% of LPA) is also higher than its climatological value. 

(c)  However, the probability of season rainfall to be deficient (below 90% of LPA) or excess (above 110% of LPA) is relatively low (less than 10%).rainfall to be deficient (below 90% of LPA) or excess (above 110% of LPA) is relatively low (less than 10%).
The IMD’s forecast of a “Normal Monsoon” lacks a high confidence level as they preferred to actually hedge their bets. As the Business Standard noted - reading between the lines, two facts emerge: one that the probability of “normal” rains at 47 % is lower than around 51%, issued last year, and two, the likelihood of “below normal rains” at 24% is higher than that of 20% during 2011.